Game design aplicado em simulações interativas educacionais

Abstract

This research aimed to investigate the effects of applying game design to a PhET interactive simulation on the teaching and learning process, and on student interest in spontaneously accessing the simulation. The methodology involved 75 high school students in an experimental design with a control group (S) and an experimental group (G). Data analysis highlighted that applying game design did not affect the acquisition of knowledge and student attitudes at the end of the class (p = 0.16). However, a significant difference (p <0.01 and r = 0.34) was observed for the retention test, being greater for the G group. The difference between the retention test and the post-test (p <0.001 and r = 0.38) was favorable for the G group. The regression curves for retention were inclined with a positive gap for the G group when compared with the S group, using previous knowledge as a covariate. The experiment was replicated in a quasiexperimental design with 64 participants, and the retention test comparison remained favorable for the G group, reinforcing the external validity of the experiment. The positive effect on knowledge retention provided by the game section is discussed with reference to cognitive load theory. The game section present in the simulation enhances its function as instructional material, facilitating the construction and automation of cognitive schemes in students' working memory. Greater student interest in accessing the PhET simulation was observed after adding a sociointeractive game design element, in this case, a high score board. This result was discussed with reference to the concept of Homo ludens. With reference to the theoretical scope of Richard E. Mayer, it is possible to understand the results obtained: learning methods by discovery, without guidance, are generally inefficient and ineffective in promoting conceptual learning. Applying game design allows the simulation to be used in both formal teaching spaces focused on learning by guided discovery and in adverse situations with digital game-based learning. As a contribution to the area of instructional design in science teaching, this thesis concludes that the game section present in a physics interactive simulation positively affects the retention of knowledge (d = 0.81) and student motivation to spontaneously access the simulation, with no evidence of cognitive load increases in students’ working memory.